The best Italian restaurants in Gibraltar.
Pasta, pizza and the full trattoria — Gibraltar's Italian tables, honestly ranked.
17 ranked by the Gibraltar Index Score — the Tripadvisor and Google ratings combined and weighted by how many people left each. How this works →
TripadvisorPanzerotto
5.0/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Street Food
TA 5.0 · 88Google 5.0 · 530Main Street & Town Centre£
TripadvisorGill's Gibraltar
4.8/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Indian
TA 5.0 · 21Google 4.8 · 148Marina Bay££–£££
Tripadvisor4 Stagioni - Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.6/ 5Index
Down 2 since 6 Sept2Italian · Pizza
TA 4.5 · 170Google 4.6 · 347South District££–£££
TripadvisorCaffe Bottega
4.6/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian
TA 5.0 · 5Google 4.6 · 99Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
Google MapsNumber 5 Bistro Gibraltar
4.6/ 5Index
Down 2 since 6 Sept2Italian · French
TA 5.0 · 1Google 4.7 · 50Main Street & Town Centre
TripadvisorMoniques Bistro & Cafe
4.4/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Seafood
TA 4.5 · 317Google 4.4 · 555Queensway Quay££–£££
TripadvisorGallo Nero
4.4/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 4.4 · 376Google 4.5 · 318Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
TripadvisorNunos At The Express
4.4/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 4.4 · 92Google 4.4 · 178Westside & Devil's Tower Road££–£££
TripadvisorMamma Mia
4.3/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 4.4 · 1,755Google 4.1 · 1,070Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
TripadvisorGianni's
4.3/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Mediterranean
TA 4.4 · 540Google 4.0 · 296Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
PizzaExpress GibraltarPizzaexpress
4.3/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 4.1 · 317Google 4.4 · 370Ocean Village££–£££
Google MapsPizzeria Plaza
4.3/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 4.3 · 172Google 4.3 · 387Main Street & Town Centre
TripadvisorPapa Luigi
4.3/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 4.6 · 161Google 4.0 · 145Westside & Devil's Tower Road££–£££
TripadvisorAmar's Bakery and Restaurant
4.2/ 5Index
Up 2 since 6 Sept2Israeli · Italian
TA 3.6 · 83Google 4.3 · 396Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
TripadvisorCafetto Nostro
4.1/ 5Index
Up 1 since 6 Sept1Italian · Deli
TA 4.0 · 4Google 4.1 · 24Ocean Village
TripadvisorTramonti Ristorante Italiano
3.9/ 5Index
Up 1 since 6 Sept1Pizza · Tuscan
TA 4.1 · 664Google 3.6 · 568Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
TripadvisorPizza Hut
3.4/ 5Index
Unchanged since 6 SeptItalian · Pizza
TA 2.4 · 141Google 3.7 · 432Main Street & Town Centre££–£££
Also italian, not yet scored
Real places, but with too few reviews across both sources to rank yet (under fifteen). They carry a write-up and will join the board once the evidence is there.
Ratings last read 6 September 2026. Ranked, never sponsored.